To add comments or start new threads please go to the full version of: The Doctor's Judgment Notes
PhysOrgForum Science, Physics and Technology Discussion Forums > Physforum > Comments / Suggestions
Pages: 1, 2

Ron
Hi Doc,
Have you explained to Lawrence why the moon doesn't even have a magnetic field?

http://www.windows.ucar.edu/tour/link=/ear...etic_field.html

Just thought he'd be interested in how that plays into his theory.
Peace,
Ron
TheDoc
QUOTE (Ron+May 29 2008, 07:44 PM)
Hi Doc,
Have you explained to Lawrence why the moon doesn't even have a magnetic field?

http://www.windows.ucar.edu/tour/link=/ear...etic_field.html

Just thought he'd be interested in how that plays into his theory.
Peace,
Ron

Nope, not yet, and I may not have a chance to anytime soon - Larry Boy hasn't shown up in about two weeks.
deadbeat
There is an important difference between calling someone idiotic, and calling them an idiot. Any parent should know this.

To describe BEHAVIOR is preferable, as it implies that the behavior is unacceptable and behavior can be changed.

To describe the PERSON as an IDIOT implies that they themselves are defective, and is far more insulting and harmful, especially to a child. And this should be avoided at all times.
DuzmA
This is the whole 'I didn't call you stupid, I said you were acting stupid' song and dance. It really is absurd. I get pissed off everytime I hear this happen. There is no difference in reality. The intent behind the words is what matters and I think its pretty clear in both cases. Everyone does idiotic things from time to time and in those instances they are idiots. Don't hide behind ambiguity or any manifestation of its brethren.


I like this thread Doc. I would like to see you review all of the main posters on this site. I don't post much anymore because I started having a hard time dealing with some posters ignoring of evidence and their refusal to engage in real discussion and debate.
TheDoc
QUOTE (deadbeat+)
There is an important difference between calling someone idiotic, and calling them an idiot.


That's like me saying "You told a lie, but you're not a liar". It makes no sense. If you lied about something, you're a liar. If I did something idiotic, for that brief instant, I was an idiot.

QUOTE (DuzmA+)
I like this thread Doc. I would like to see you review all of the main posters on this site.


I'm getting there. Expect a few new additions in the next couple of days.

QUOTE
I don't post much anymore because I started having a hard time dealing with some posters ignoring of evidence and their refusal to engage in real discussion and debate.


So? Just keep cranking out logical, level-headed debates and you're good to go!
Gorgeous
QUOTE (DuzmA+Jun 2 2008, 02:16 AM)
This is the whole 'I didn't call you stupid, I said you were acting stupid' song and dance. It really is absurd. I get pissed off everytime I hear this happen. There is no difference in reality. The intent behind the words is what matters and I think its pretty clear in both cases. Everyone does idiotic things from time to time and in those instances they are idiots. Don't hide behind ambiguity or any manifestation of its brethren.


I like this thread Doc. I would like to see you review all of the main posters on this site. I don't post much anymore because I started having a hard time dealing with some posters ignoring of evidence and their refusal to engage in real discussion and debate.

Good post.

People deny obvious truths and other evidence for political (self-interested) reasons. Such people do not usually want to understand that 'debate' is designed to thrash out what is necessarily real concerning relevant topics, but are really trying to somehow 'force' people to agree with them, on a personal level' for ego-related (again, 'political' self-interested) reasons.

Personally, I only come here for a psychology lesson! biggrin.gif




g.
soundhertz
Why not provide some balance and discuss posters you do like and some reasons why? I just wanted to see some positive comments as I think the majority of the posters here are not of the irritating ilk. btw I wanted to post this as a guest since I'm on a work contractor's computer, and I was denied that attempt. Anyone know why? I see guests post all the time.
MjolnirPants
QUOTE (Edward 3+May 26 2008, 10:22 AM)
If Doc and Sec knew anything about normal human relationships...

I ain't gonna disagree wit ya on that, even tho yer wrong, but I will say this:
If you knew anythin about normal human behavior, you'd know that them two know all about normal human relationships.
That's why they got better feedback than you wink.gif
Confused2
"If you knew anythin about normal human behavior.." said the guy with twelve aliases and a hammer in his pants.
TheDoc
QUOTE (soundhertz+)
Why not provide some balance and discuss posters you do like and some reasons why?


I've already done that in this thread.

QUOTE (Confused2+)
"If you knew anythin about normal human behavior.." said the guy with twelve aliases


Do point out what "aliases" MjolnirPants has.

QUOTE
and a hammer in his pants.


You're not familiar with Norse Mythology, are you?
TheDoc
QUOTE (newton in my feedback+)
an angry sockpuppet that gets faux upset about being called a sockpuppet.

feels the need to consistently give me negatives, even though we NEVER discuss science, and i've barely been posting anymore. holy small man syndrome, batman!

thedic is more like it.


I've challenged you several times to prove I'm a sockpuppet, newton, and you haven't done so. Not even once. You just ran away every time.

So I'm giving you this one last shot at it, newton. Prove that I am a sockpuppet. Do it, right here, in this thread, out in public. Expose me, once and for all. Prove that I am a sockpuppet. Prove the one thing you haven't been able to prove the last three months. Come on, for someone so "experienced" in these things, you shouldn't even break a sweat. wink.gif


Oh. And as for your quip about me being "angry". Your Fail Meter is perilously close to critical. wink.gif
Confused2
QUOTE (TheDoc+)
Do point out what "aliases" MjolnirPants has.


OK.. let's start with one we can agree about ..

From sec's feedback we see TheDoc's comment "EXTERMINATE" .. the cry of many a ten year old .. also fivedoughnut and yourself .. good enough?

Now pick one from the following list that you DON'T think is a 5D sockpuppet .. we can check for the 5D trademark and see if we agree about that one .. or not.

The candidates are:-
Rabbit, Princess Bluebell, Cecil P Abstract, Crankoid, Username, Moomin, <Max>, Lizzy Frog, Agent X20, sec and MjolinirPants .. with the original fivedoughnut this is a total of 12 aliases.

Would I be right in thinking you feel sockpuppets are a good thing when they work in your favour but you don't like being accused of being a 'sock-puppet'?

C2.
Trippy
QUOTE (Confused2+Jun 3 2008, 08:29 PM)
QUOTE (TheDoc+)
Do point out what "aliases" MjolnirPants has.


OK.. let's start with one we can agree about ..

From sec's feedback we see TheDoc's comment "EXTERMINATE" .. the cry of many a ten year old .. also fivedoughnut and yourself .. good enough?

Now pick one from the following list that you DON'T think is a 5D sockpuppet .. we can check for the 5D trademark and see if we agree about that one .. or not.

The candidates are:-
Rabbit, Princess Bluebell, Cecil P Abstract, Crankoid, Username, Moomin, <Max>, Lizzy Frog, Agent X20, sec and MjolinirPants .. with the original fivedoughnut this is a total of 12 aliases.

Would I be right in thinking you feel sockpuppets are a good thing when they work in your favour but you don't like being accused of being a 'sock-puppet'?

C2.

Too funny.

And at least some of those are wrong.
Bloy
QUOTE (MjolnirPants+Jun 2 2008, 10:20 AM)
I ain't gonna disagree wit ya on that, even tho yer wrong, but I will say this:
If you knew anythin about normal human behavior, you'd know that them two know all about normal human relationships.
That's why they got better feedback than you wink.gif

what the hell is this garbage??

...actually the whole thread!!
Trippy
QUOTE (gmilam+May 22 2008, 09:24 AM)
I am a total idiot! (Goo goo ga joob)

I agree.
Confused2
QUOTE (Trippy+)
And at least some of those are wrong.


Yes .. MjolnirPants looks like he might know some stuff ..

We're still looking at eleven sockpuppets and a guy with a hammer in his pants .. are we in the realms of 'normal' behaviour or are we still in the 'not normal' behaviour?

-C2.
MjolnirPants
QUOTE (Confused2+Jun 2 2008, 07:54 PM)
said the guy with twelve aliases

Wrong! laugh.gif
Yer jes shootin into the treeline, aintya? Sorry, but ya missed.

QUOTE
and a hammer in his pants.

Hey! Ya sunk my destroyer!
Big hammer, too. 75lb jackhammer, as a matter o fact. wink.gif
(an it still shoots lightnin!)

QUOTE (->
QUOTE
and a hammer in his pants.

Hey! Ya sunk my destroyer!
Big hammer, too. 75lb jackhammer, as a matter o fact. wink.gif
(an it still shoots lightnin!)

OK.. let's start with one we can agree about ..

Go check out Sapo's Joint. Sign up. You can see IP addresses an try to come up with a good explaination why me an all them folks you listed who are members o the Joint have different IP addresses. wink.gif

Whassamatta, son? You annoyed that I made a valid point which makes yer buddy Eddy's dumb claim obvious fer what it is? Don't it just get yer goat every time some redneck with a prediliction fer Norse mythology comes along and points out how dumb yer side o the argument is? I know it pisses me off. Well, it would if it ever happened, that is.

QUOTE
We're still looking at eleven sockpuppets and a guy with a hammer in his pants .. are we in the realms of 'normal' behaviour or are we still in the 'not normal' behaviour?

Well, I ain't got no sockpuppets, son. An I'd keep my hammer in my shoe, but it just don't fit! Where you keep yer hammer?
In yer head, I bet. wink.gif

QUOTE (->
QUOTE
We're still looking at eleven sockpuppets and a guy with a hammer in his pants .. are we in the realms of 'normal' behaviour or are we still in the 'not normal' behaviour?

Well, I ain't got no sockpuppets, son. An I'd keep my hammer in my shoe, but it just don't fit! Where you keep yer hammer?
In yer head, I bet. wink.gif

what the hell is this garbage??

Most folk generally refer to it as "a good point."
You can call it whatever you like though.


Ain't it funny how I come along an make a good point, an all the arguing folks do with me don't involve them makin a point o their own? laugh.gif
ubavontuba
TheDoc,

Aw, man! I just skimmed the whole thread and saw nothing on me. I guess I'm either unnotable, or not idiotic enough to be included in your criticisms.

I liked your references to Doctor Who. I was a big fan of the show in... well, suffice it to say... Tom Baker was playing The Doctor. I think I still have some old posters from then. My brother and I used to make jokes about the things you could do with all those dead, but still indestructible Cybermen.
TheDoc
QUOTE (Confused2+)
From sec's feedback we see TheDoc's comment "EXTERMINATE" .. the cry of many a ten year old .. also fivedoughnut and yourself ..


You do know what "exterminate" refers to, right?

QUOTE
good enough?


No.

QUOTE (->
QUOTE
good enough?


No.

Now pick one from the following list that you DON'T think is a 5D sockpuppet .. we can check for the 5D trademark and see if we agree about that one .. or not.

The candidates are:-
Rabbit, Princess Bluebell, Cecil P Abstract, Crankoid, Username, Moomin, <Max>, Lizzy Frog, Agent X20, sec and MjolinirPants .. with the original fivedoughnut this is a total of 12 aliases.


<Max> and MjolnirPants.

QUOTE
We're still looking at eleven sockpuppets and a guy with a hammer in his pants .. are we in the realms of 'normal' behaviour or are we still in the 'not normal' behaviour?


Creating a sockpuppet is, as demonstrated by the lists in this thread, normal behavior.

Maybe I'll come up with a sockpuppet! I'll call him..."The Master" ph34r.gif

QUOTE (->
QUOTE
We're still looking at eleven sockpuppets and a guy with a hammer in his pants .. are we in the realms of 'normal' behaviour or are we still in the 'not normal' behaviour?


Creating a sockpuppet is, as demonstrated by the lists in this thread, normal behavior.

Maybe I'll come up with a sockpuppet! I'll call him..."The Master" ph34r.gif

Aw, man! I just skimmed the whole thread and saw nothing on me. I guess I'm either unnotable


Wrong! Didn't I announce a couple of days ago that new entries were on the way?

QUOTE
or not idiotic enough to be included in your criticisms.


Don't be so sure of that tongue.gif

QUOTE (->
QUOTE
or not idiotic enough to be included in your criticisms.


Don't be so sure of that tongue.gif

My brother and I used to make jokes about the things you could do with all those dead, but still indestructible Cybermen.


I'd like to see a battalion of Cybermen vs. Iron Man ph34r.gif
ubavontuba
QUOTE (TheDoc+Jun 4 2008, 03:46 AM)
Don't be so sure of that tongue.gif

Looking forward to it.

QUOTE
I'd like to see a battalion of Cybermen vs. Iron Man  ph34r.gif

Well, if they move like they did in the show, the cybermen would never catch him!
TheDoc
mott.carl, <Max>, and IAMoraes
IAMoraes
QUOTE (TheDoc+Jun 6 2008, 07:09 PM)
mott.carl, <Max>, and IAMoraes

My proudest moment!

After youknowwho left cursing everyone except me (who does he think he is?! How dare he?!) I knew someone was bound to remember I exist!

Thank you! I just looked in the mirror: I am in fact there!

Uh, I think I will put some clothes on now...



(Who does he think he is?! HOW DARE HE?!)
TheDoc
dad1

Edit: This is my post #1800.
Zarkov
The Doc and ilk, are total idiots

I have never seen anything of worth posted by this clique of forum lice.

I am very surprised that the moderators entertain their presence... they make a mockery of a science forum... especially one that should be of a high standard......

Threads like this just attract and encourage the rabble..... the mass ignorant !

Yes, I am an elitist, a scientist that has no time for such trash.
excaza
QUOTE (Zarkov+Jun 17 2008, 06:35 AM)
The Doc and ilk, are total idiots

I have never seen anything of worth posted by this clique of forum lice.

I am very surprised that the moderators entertain their presence... they make a mockery of a science forum... especially one that should be of a high standard......

Threads like this just attract and encourage the rabble..... the mass ignorant !

Yes, I am an elitist, a scientist that has no time for such trash.

I think you have "The Doc and ilk" confused with your reflection in a mirror.
TheDoc
QUOTE (Zarkov+)
The Doc and ilk, are total idiots


Whereas Zarkov is not an idiot, right? rolleyes.gif

QUOTE
I have never seen anything of worth posted by this clique of forum lice.


You are such a freaking liar.

N O M

BigDumbWeirdo

BigDumbWeirdo

BigDumbWeirdo

TheDoc

TheDoc

TheDoc

And those are just examples from three people. And there's more where those posts came from, not to mention posts by excaza, Trippy, barakn, adoucette and MjolnirPants.

Do you feel like taking that statement back right about now?

QUOTE (->
QUOTE
I have never seen anything of worth posted by this clique of forum lice.


You are such a freaking liar.

N O M

BigDumbWeirdo

BigDumbWeirdo

BigDumbWeirdo

TheDoc

TheDoc

TheDoc

And those are just examples from three people. And there's more where those posts came from, not to mention posts by excaza, Trippy, barakn, adoucette and MjolnirPants.

Do you feel like taking that statement back right about now?

I am very surprised that the moderators entertain their presence... they make a mockery of a science forum... especially one that should be of a high standard......


I'm equally suprised that they allow egocentric idiots like you here.

QUOTE
Threads like this just attract and encourage the rabble..... the mass ignorant !


Liar. I've already stated the purpose of this thread, lying about it won't make you look any more credible.

QUOTE (->
QUOTE
Threads like this just attract and encourage the rabble..... the mass ignorant !


Liar. I've already stated the purpose of this thread, lying about it won't make you look any more credible.

Yes, I am an elitist, a scientist that has no time for such trash.


You freaking LIAR. You aren't a scientist. You are a fraud. You're a liar, a hypocrite, a delusional nutjob, but you are most certainly NOT a scientist. You wouldn't last five seconds on a real, moderated physics forum.
PhysOrg scientific forums are totally dedicated to science, physics, and technology. Besides topical forums such as nanotechnology, quantum physics, silicon and III-V technology, applied physics, materials, space and others, you can also join our news and publications discussions. We also provide an off-topic forum category. If you need specific help on a scientific problem or have a question related to physics or technology, visit the PhysOrg Forums. Here you’ll find experts from various fields online every day.
To quit out of "lo-fi" mode and return to the regular forums, please click here.