To add comments or start new threads please go to the full version of: Sarcasm Seen As Evolutionary Survival Skill.
PhysOrgForum Science, Physics and Technology Discussion Forums > General Sci-Tech Discussions > Creation / Evolution

photojack
"Sarcasm Seen as Evolutionary Survival Skill."

Meredith F. Small, LiveScience's Human Nature Columnist.
LiveScience.com

Humans are fundamentally social animals. Our social nature means that we interact with each other in positive, friendly ways, and it also means we know how to manipulate others in a very negative way.

Neurophysiologist Katherine Rankin at the University of California, San Francisco, has also recently discovered that sarcasm, which is both positively funny and negatively nasty, plays an important part in human social interaction.

So what?

I mean really, who cares? Oh for God's sake. Don't you have anything better to do that read this column?

According to Dr. Rankin, if you didn't get the sarcastic tone of the previous sentences you must have some damage to your parahippocampal gyrus which is located in the right brain. People with dementia, or head injuries in that area, often lose the ability to pick up on sarcasm, and so they don't respond in a socially appropriate ways.

Presumably, this is a pathology, which in turn suggests that sarcasm is part of human nature and probably an evolutionarily good thing.

How might something so, well, sarcastic as sarcasm, be part of the human social toolbox?

Evolutionary biologists claim that sociality is what has made humans such a successful species. We are masters at what anthropologists and others call "social intelligence." We recognize and keep track of hundreds of relationships, and we easily distinguish between enemies and friends.

More important, we run our lives by social calculation. A favor is mentally recorded and paid back, sometimes many years later. Likewise, insults are marked down on the mental score card in indelible ink. And we are constantly bickering and making up, even with people we love.

Sarcasm, then, is a verbal hammer that connects people in both a negative and positive way. We know that sense of humor is important to relationships; if someone doesn't get your jokes, they aren't likely to be your friend (or at least that's my bottom line about friendship). Sarcasm is simply humor's dark side, and it would be just as disconcerting if a friend didn't get your snide remarks.

It's also easy to imagine how sarcasm might be selected over time as evolutionarily crucial. Imagine two ancient humans running across the savannah with a hungry lion in pursuit. One guy says to the other, "Are we having fun yet?" and the other just looks blank and stops to figure out what in the world his pal meant by that remark. End of friendship, end of one guy's contribution to the future of the human gene pool.

Fast forward a few million years and the network of human relationships is wider and more complex, and just as important to survival. The corporate chairman throws out a sarcastic remark and those who "get" it laugh, smile, and gain favor. In the same way, if the chair never makes a remark, sarcastic people are making them behind his or her back, forming a clique by their mutually negative, but funny, comments. Either way, sarcasm plays a role in making and breaking alliances and friendship.

Thanks goodness, because life without out sarcasm would be a dull and way too nice place to be, if you ask me.

Video: Humor and the Sexes
Top 10 Mysteries of the Mind
Emotional Wiring Different in Women and Men
Meredith F. Small is an anthropologist at Cornell University. She is also the author of "Our Babies, Ourselves; How Biology and Culture Shape the Way We Parent" (link) and "The Culture of Our Discontent; Beyond the Medical Model of Mental Illness" (link).

Original Story: Sarcasm Seen as Evolutionary Survival Skill

Please go to the original link for full access to internal links within the article at:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/livescience/200806...rysurvivalskill

Gee! I hope g. sees this and makes some comments. She has been way more positively funny and far less negatively nasty than in the past. ohmy.gif We have truly reconciled! wub.gif wink.gif

newguy
QUOTE
Thank goodness, because life without out sarcasm would be a dull and way too nice place to be, if you ask me.


You might want to add "thank newguy"... ohmy.gif

biggrin.gif
Sinister Utopia
QUOTE (newguy+Jun 20 2008, 10:02 PM)

You might want to add "thank newguy"... ohmy.gif

biggrin.gif

I agree biggrin.gif
Alcari
Well, I can add from experience that sarcasm will probably help my genes spread, seeing how the potential recipient says she "Loves my sarcastic comments" wink.gif

But I doubt the ability for sarcasm is genetic, though I guess if you teach your children sarcasm, that works as well.

QUOTE
She has been way more positively funny and far less negatively nasty than in the past.  We have truly reconciled!

Argh, suddenly i've got this stinging sensation in the right half of my head, somewhere around the parahippocampal gyrus wink.gif
Gorgeous
QUOTE (photojack+Jun 20 2008, 05:32 AM)
Gee! I hope g. sees this and makes some comments. She has been way more positively funny and far less negatively nasty than in the past.  ohmy.gif  We have truly reconciled!  wub.gif  wink.gif

You are quite correct with this pj!

There was a time i would have reacted, even to what you have just posted, and taken it personally, but when I think about it you are correct. However, it may not be for the same reasons that you yourself imagine. biggrin.gif

I am very pleased that you see me as "far less negatively nasty than in the past". smile.gif I think we were just at cross purposes, coming from different cultures, it is easy to take things in ways they are not intented.

Until I started posting here, I was not so aware of how much of a problem the 'science versus religion' issue is with Americans, and this is an aspect of 'Americanism' that is being exported along with the culture to the rest of the world. It is actually quite a sad thing to see people at each others' throats over such stupid political issues.



Sarcasm, I think, is something less than the kind of humour we would like to fill our lives with, but it has developed this way because of the ways we live our 'sarcastic' lives. I am sure that pj will agree that Humans cannot continue to pollute this wonderful Planet, but that pollution is an extention of the pollution of incorrect thinking that plagues us as a species, currently. One of the ways to deal with this is to laugh at it, laugh at ourselves when we are ridiculous, and we all are, sometimes. This materialises as 'sarcastic' humour. This sarcastic humour also has 'levels' that are connected to our 'moral' outlooks. Again, these are all as different as people are.

Some aspects of our lives are so ridiculous that we have to either laugh or cry. Therein lies our choice. When reason breaks down, this is what we are left with.


Of course, us brits are past masters of sarcasm...
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=Vsm3FObZ1sI&...feature=related
...sometimes it is all there is left!



g.
photojack
QUOTE
Of course, us brits are past masters of sarcasm...
g. quote.

What do you mean, PAST? I thought they are the current masters of sarcasm. I'll just have to turn this funny forum into the "funny farm!" ((laugh.gif))
I'll have to hone up on my evolutionary survival skills like the great Benny Hill did.!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=cLKaLvrtn-8

Oops! The other guy won the woman's charms, not Benny Hill. tongue.gif
Gorgeous
QUOTE (photojack+Jun 20 2008, 06:35 PM)
g. quote.

What do you mean, PAST? I thought they are the current masters of sarcasm. I'll just have to turn this funny forum into the "funny farm!" ((laugh.gif))
I'll have to hone up on my evolutionary survival skills like the great Benny Hill did.!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=cLKaLvrtn-8

Oops! The other guy won the woman's charms, not Benny Hill. tongue.gif

Ok, I'll give you that. We DO have Gordon Brown! tongue.gif


g.
Dr Fred A Wolf
QUOTE (Gorgeous+Jun 21 2008, 09:21 AM)
Ok, I'll give you that. We DO have Gordon Brown! tongue.gif


g.

Yeah, he's a real fukker ....... want a sexual T-Rex genie darling? biggrin.gif
Gorgeous
QUOTE (Dr Fred A Wolf+Jun 21 2008, 02:39 AM)
Yeah, he's a real fukker ....... want a sexual T-Rex genie darling?  biggrin.gif

Marc Bolan? That must be the 'stiffy' you have been referring to! biggrin.gif



g.
PhysOrg scientific forums are totally dedicated to science, physics, and technology. Besides topical forums such as nanotechnology, quantum physics, silicon and III-V technology, applied physics, materials, space and others, you can also join our news and publications discussions. We also provide an off-topic forum category. If you need specific help on a scientific problem or have a question related to physics or technology, visit the PhysOrg Forums. Here you’ll find experts from various fields online every day.
To quit out of "lo-fi" mode and return to the regular forums, please click here.